WHAT IS MEDIATION?

Chris Breedon Mediator at Prospero Mediation and Training.

Interpersonal Conflict Mediation is a form of alternative dispute resolution that is delivered by a neutral third party, the mediator, who helps participants in conflict to reach a mutually acceptable resolution. Mediation gives the participants more control over the outcome of their conflict. The mediator facilitates communication and negotiation between the participants and does not offer solutions.  

As a process Mediation is voluntary and confidential. It is less expensive and time-consuming than internal investigations and disciplinary process and going to court. Mediation can be used to resolve a wide range of conflict, including workplace disagreements, family conflicts, neighbourhood disputes, to name a few. There is a mediation process for Commercial and Civil disputes, but the process is very different and more akin to negotiation and often involves lawyers. Interpersonal Conflict Mediation is a flexible process that can be adjusted to meet the specific needs of the participants. The goal of Mediation is to help the participants repair damaged relationships by finding common ground and reaching a resolution that meets their needs and interests. It is a more collaborative to conflict resolution ideally ending on a win/win basis.

Mediation differs from other conflict resolution methods such as arbitration and litigation by focusing on collaboration and reaching a mutually beneficial agreement. It can lead to cost savings, quicker resolution, and improved relationships between participants compared to alternative processes.

Understanding the Basics of Mediation

In mediation, the participants have the opportunity to express their concerns and interests in a safe and neutral environment. The mediator will speak to each of the participants individually to fully appreciate the background and situation. They will then hold a joint meeting with all the participants. The mediator facilitates communication between the participants, ensuring that each side has the chance to be heard and understood. This often leads to a better understanding of the underlying issues and help the participants find common ground. Being neutral the mediator does not take sides or make judgments about who is right or wrong. Instead, they help the participants explore their options and work towards an agreement that is acceptable to all. This can involve exploring different ideas and solutions, and potentially finding compromises that meet the needs of those involved. However, in compromises participants must be happy with what they have given up so that this does not become the source of future conflict. The mediator will help stress test these collaborations. If applicable the mediator may also help the participants draft a written agreement detailing the terms of their resolution. This agreement is not generally a legal agreement but more of a moral one. In Civil/Commercial cases the agreement is more likely to be legally enforceable.

The Role of a Mediator in Conflict Resolution

The mediator plays a vital role in the process, acting as a neutral facilitator who helps the participants to communicate effectively and work towards a resolution. They are trained to manage conflict and deliver the process in a fair and impartial manner. Rather than offering solutions the mediator helps the participants to find their own. They will create a safe environment for the participants to engage in open and honest dialogue. They will also help the participants to express their concerns and interests, using techniques such as active listening, reframing, and asking questions. The mediator will keep the participants focused on the issues and stop the conversation being undermined by emotions or personal attacks. The mediator may also help the participants to explore solutions that they may not have considered on their own. This can involve examining various ideas and options and finding a way that meet the needs of both participants. The end game is for the mediator to help the participants find an acceptable resolution that also resets the relationship and reducing the chance of future conflict.

How Mediation Differs from Other Conflict Resolution Methods

Mediation differs from other conflict resolution methods, such as negotiation arbitration or litigation, in several aspects. Unlike arbitration, where a third party makes a binding decision for the participants, mediation gives the participants total control over the resolution of their conflict.  

Another method is litigation, which can be extremely costly and time-consuming when compared to mediation. Litigation is often in the public domain so there is little privacy or confidentiality. Mediation, by its very nature is often less adversarial than litigation, as it encourages collaboration and a win/win solution rather than a win/lose.  

The Benefits of Choosing Mediation

There are many benefits to choosing mediation as a method of conflict resolution. The first is that it allows the participants to have control over the outcome of their dispute. They actively participate in the process and work towards a solution that meets their needs and interests. This often leads to more lasting outcomes than those imposed by a judge or arbitrator. Mediation is quicker and a lot less expensive than going to court. It is scheduled at a mutually convenient time for all participants and is not subject to the delays and backlogs of the court system. Furthermore, mediation helps to repair relationships between the participants, as it encourages open communication and collaboration rather than confrontation and hostility. It is truly a win/win process. Mediation is a flexible process tailored to the specific needs of the participants. Using various techniques and working with the participants the mediator facilitates work towards a resolution that meets their unique circumstances. This can lead to more creative and bespoke solutions than those imposed by a judge or arbitrator.

Common Misconceptions About Mediation

There are several common misconceptions about mediation that may prevent people from considering it as an option for resolving conflict. One is that mediation is only for simple issues but in fact it can be utilised for a wide range of interpersonal/workplace conflicts. Some believe that mediation is only for people who are on good terms with each other, but it is equally effective is significant breakdown in relationship between the participants. Some people also mistakenly believe that mediation is only for people who are willing to compromise or give in, when in fact it is designed to be collaborative and to help participants find solutions that meet their needs and interests.  

When to Consider Mediation for Resolving Interpersonal Disputes

There are several situations in which mediation may be a beneficial option for resolving disputes. Mediation is effective in workplace conflicts, such as employee grievances or interpersonal disputes between employees or employees and management. It can help you to address underlying issues and improve communication within an organization. Additionally, if people are involved in a community or neighbourhood dispute, such as noise complaints or property disagreements, mediation can help them to find common ground and reach a solution that benefits everyone.  

In summary Mediation is a unique tool for solving conflicts across a wide range of issues. It has many advantages over other conflict resolution methods, including, but not limited to, greater control over the outcome, quicker and less expensive processes, and more collaborative and lasting agreements. By understanding the basics of mediation and its benefits, and by dispelling common misconceptions about it, you can make an informed decision about whether it is right process for you when facing conflict.

‍